We Found A Threatening Letter In Our Mailbox, And We Have A Pretty Good Idea Who Sent It

I never imagined that something as ordinary as leaves falling from our trees would eventually turn into a neighborhood conflict involving anonymous threats and accusations. My husband and I have lived in our home for several years, and one of the things we have always loved most about our property is the beautiful trees surrounding our backyard. They provide shade during the summer, make the garden feel peaceful, and add a lot of character to our home. Some of them were already there when we moved in, while others were planted by us over the years. We have always taken good care of them, trimming branches when necessary and making sure they remain healthy. We never considered them a problem until our neighbor started complaining about the leaves.
At first, his complaints seemed relatively harmless. During autumn, leaves naturally fall from trees, and some of them occasionally get carried by the wind into neighboring yards. We understand that nobody enjoys constantly cleaning leaves from their driveway or garden, but this is simply part of living in a neighborhood with mature trees. We have never expected our neighbors to clean our property, and whenever leaves collect near the fence on our side, we take care of them ourselves. However, our neighbor seemed particularly bothered by the situation. He mentioned it several times whenever we crossed paths outside, usually making comments about how much work our trees were creating for him. We politely apologized for the inconvenience, even though there was nothing unusual or intentional about what was happening.
Things became more uncomfortable when he started making direct suggestions that we should remove some of the trees. The first time, he said it casually, almost as if he were making a friendly recommendation. He pointed toward a large tree near the property line and mentioned that getting rid of it would make his yard much easier to maintain. My husband simply smiled and explained that we had no plans to remove a healthy tree just because some leaves occasionally crossed the fence. Our neighbor did not seem happy with that response. A few days later, he brought up the same subject again, this time sounding much more serious. He suggested that we should at least cut down the branches hanging near his property. We explained that the branches were not causing any damage and that we would consider reasonable trimming if there were an actual issue.
After those conversations, we tried not to make a big deal out of his behavior. We continued maintaining our garden, cleaning up fallen leaves, and keeping our side of the property neat. We also made sure that no branches were growing dangerously close to his house or creating an obvious safety concern. Unfortunately, our neighbor did not seem interested in finding a reasonable compromise. Whenever leaves blew into his yard, he appeared irritated, and sometimes we could hear him complaining while working outside. We started feeling uncomfortable whenever we saw him because we never knew whether he would greet us normally or make another comment about our trees. My husband thought we should simply ignore him unless he approached us directly, and I agreed that arguing over something so minor would only make the situation worse.
Then, one morning, we discovered something that completely changed how we viewed the situation. My husband went outside to collect the mail and found an envelope sitting inside our mailbox. There was no return address, no stamp, and no name written anywhere on it. At first, we assumed it might have been something accidentally delivered to us, but when he opened it, we realized it was a letter specifically addressed to the people living in our house. The message was short, but the wording was extremely aggressive. Whoever had written it complained about our trees and the leaves blowing into their yard. The person then warned us that if we continued allowing the leaves to become a problem, they would take matters into their own hands and cut down our trees. There was no signature, no explanation, and absolutely nothing that identified the sender.
I read the letter several times because I honestly could not believe someone would go that far over fallen leaves. We were not talking about a dangerous tree, damaged fencing, or branches threatening someone’s roof. We were talking about leaves being carried by the wind from one yard to another. What bothered me most was the fact that the person had chosen to remain anonymous while making a direct threat against our property. My husband was equally upset, although he tried to stay calm. We immediately started discussing who might have left it. Considering the earlier complaints and repeated conversations about removing our trees, we had a pretty good idea who was responsible. Our next-door neighbor had been the only person who had repeatedly expressed this level of frustration about the leaves.
However, neither of us wanted to accuse him without actual proof. There was always a possibility that someone else had written the letter, even if that seemed unlikely. We discussed whether we should simply knock on his door and ask if he knew anything about it, but I worried that confronting him might turn an uncomfortable situation into a much bigger argument. My husband suggested keeping the letter somewhere safe in case we needed it later. We also decided to take photographs of the envelope and its contents so we would have a record of exactly what had been written. We did not respond by leaving a message in his mailbox or making threats of our own. We wanted to handle the situation carefully rather than give anyone a reason to claim that we were behaving aggressively.
Since receiving the letter, we have become much more aware of what happens around our property. Whenever we hear someone near the fence or notice unusual activity around the trees, we naturally pay more attention. We have also started documenting the condition of the trees and taking pictures of the areas closest to the property line. We are not interested in creating unnecessary drama, but we also do not believe someone should be allowed to threaten or damage our property simply because they dislike cleaning up leaves. If there is a legitimate concern about overhanging branches or property boundaries, we are willing to discuss it like reasonable adults. What we are not willing to do is remove healthy trees because an unidentified person has decided that they are an inconvenience.
Now we are stuck wondering what the right next step should be. Part of me thinks we should speak directly with our neighbor and calmly explain that we received a threatening letter and suspect he may know something about it. Another part of me believes that giving him an opportunity to deny everything could make the situation even more uncomfortable, especially if he really was responsible. My husband thinks we should avoid confronting anyone until we have stronger evidence and should consider contacting the appropriate local authorities if the threats continue or if anyone attempts to damage the trees. We both agree that we should not give in to intimidation, but we also do not want a long-running feud with someone who lives right next door. Would we be wrong for refusing to cut down our trees and taking the anonymous threat seriously, even though the falling leaves are genuinely annoying for our neighbor? And should we confront the person we strongly suspect, or wait until we have actual proof?
Read Story…
A or B: Someone left an unsigned letter in our mailbox saying they’ll cut down our trees if our leaves keep blowing into their yard. We think we know who
I never imagined that something as simple as having a few trees in our backyard would eventually turn into a stressful situation with one of our neighbors. My husband and I have lived in our home for several years, and one of the things we have always enjoyed about the property is the beautiful outdoor space. We have several chestnut trees growing in our yard, and they have been there for a long time. They provide shade during the warmer months, make the garden look beautiful, and give us a sense of privacy from the neighboring properties. We have always considered them part of our home, and we have never had any reason to think they would become a problem for someone else.
The only downside is that when autumn arrives, the trees start dropping an enormous number of leaves. Anyone who has chestnut trees knows that they can create quite a mess during this time of year. The leaves fall almost constantly, and whenever the wind picks up, many of them end up blowing beyond our fence and into the yard next door. We understand that this can be frustrating for our neighbor, especially if he prefers keeping his lawn completely clean.
We are not deliberately allowing leaves to collect on his property, and we do make an effort to rake them up regularly. However, we both work and have other responsibilities, so we do not always manage to clean everything immediately. Sometimes we get to it the same afternoon, while other times it takes a day or two.
Until recently, this arrangement had never caused a serious disagreement. We assumed that our neighbor understood that falling leaves were simply part of living near trees. We have never asked him to clean our yard, and we have never expected him to take responsibility for maintaining our property. Whenever we notice a large number of leaves gathering near the fence, we try to collect them and dispose of them properly.
We also occasionally clean the areas around the boundary because we do not want to create unnecessary problems with anyone living nearby. We believe neighbors should make reasonable efforts to respect one another, but we also think there needs to be some understanding that nobody can completely control what the wind carries into another person’s yard.
Unfortunately, the relationship with the neighbor on that particular side of our property has never been especially friendly. We have had disagreements with him in the past, although none of them involved the trees. He has occasionally complained about other minor things, and some of our previous interactions have left us feeling that he is not particularly interested in resolving disagreements peacefully. We have tried to avoid unnecessary conversations with him because we do not want every small neighborhood issue to become an argument. Despite that history, he has never directly approached us to complain about the chestnut leaves. Not once has he knocked on our door, mentioned the problem while we were outside, or politely asked whether we could rake more frequently during the autumn months.
If he had simply spoken to us like a reasonable person, we probably would have made an extra effort. We are not unreasonable people, and we understand that fallen leaves can become annoying when they repeatedly collect in the same place. We could easily adjust our routine and check the fence line more often. We might even have agreed to rake the area every evening during the busiest part of the season. It would not have been a major inconvenience, especially if it meant keeping a peaceful relationship with someone who lives right beside us. However, we cannot respond to a request that nobody has actually made. Instead of talking to us, someone decided to take a much more disturbing approach.
A few days ago, my husband went outside to collect the mail and noticed an unusual letter inside our mailbox. There was no stamp, no return address, and no name identifying the person who had left it. It looked as though someone had personally placed it there rather than sending it through the postal service. Naturally, we were curious about what it contained. When my husband opened the envelope, he found a short handwritten message that immediately made both of us uncomfortable. It said, “Your leaves are all over my yard again. Deal with it or I’ll deal with those trees myself.” That was the entire message. There was no attempt to explain the problem, no request for us to clean anything, and no indication that the person wanted to have a normal conversation. It was simply a warning that someone intended to take matters into their own hands.
We read the message several times, trying to understand whether the person was seriously threatening to damage or destroy our trees. The wording was vague enough that someone could later claim it was only an angry comment, but we did not see it that way. Saying that someone will deal with our trees themselves is not a normal way to complain about leaves.
Those trees are growing on our property, and we have invested time and effort into maintaining our yard. Even if our neighbor is genuinely frustrated by the leaves, that does not give anyone permission to enter our property or damage something that belongs to us. My first thought was that the neighbor on that side had probably written the letter. Considering our previous disagreements and the fact that he is the person most directly affected by the falling leaves, he was the obvious person who came to mind. Still, we have no actual proof that he was responsible, so we cannot honestly say we know for certain.
After discussing what had happened, we decided to install security cameras around our property. We had considered getting cameras before, but this incident finally convinced us that it was worth doing.
We wanted to have a record of anyone approaching our mailbox, walking near the fence, or entering areas around the trees.
We also wanted to make sure that if something happened to the trees, we would have evidence instead of relying on assumptions. The cameras are now positioned to cover the important areas around our home, including the sections closest to the neighboring property. We have also kept the original letter and taken photographs of it. We do not want to lose something that could become important if the situation gets worse.
The timing has made everything even more frustrating because we are currently in the middle of leaf season. The chestnut trees are still dropping leaves every day, and the wind continues carrying some of them into the neighboring yard. We have not suddenly stopped cleaning our property, but it is almost impossible to collect every single leaf before another batch falls. Even when we rake everything in the morning, the yard can look completely different by the afternoon. We have started checking the area more frequently, and we are trying to keep the leaves from accumulating near the fence. At the same time, we do not want to feel as though we have to constantly monitor our trees because someone has threatened to damage them. It is our home, and we should be able to enjoy our own yard without worrying about an anonymous message.
Now my husband and I disagree about how seriously we should escalate the situation. He believes we should take the letter to the police, explain that someone has threatened to damage our property, and ask what steps we can take to protect ourselves. He also wants us to put up clear no-trespassing signs so there can be no confusion about whether someone is allowed to enter our property. His position is that we should establish boundaries now rather than wait until something actually happens. I understand his reasoning because we have no idea whether the person who wrote the letter was simply angry or genuinely planning to cut down our trees. However, I also worry that immediately involving the police could make an already uncomfortable neighbor situation much worse, especially if we cannot prove who sent the message.
My position is that we should rake the leaves more frequently for the rest of the season while keeping the letter, monitoring the cameras, and documenting anything unusual. We have not always cleaned the leaves as quickly as we could have, and I am willing to accept that making a little more effort might prevent further complaints.
I do not think that means we are admitting fault or allowing someone to threaten us. It simply means we are choosing the easiest possible solution to the original problem. If the neighbor is upset because leaves are collecting in his yard, removing them more often could take away the reason for his complaints.
But I also do not want to reward threatening behavior or create the impression that anonymous intimidation is an acceptable way to communicate with us.
My husband argues that the issue is no longer just about leaves. According to him, the moment someone threatened to deal with our trees personally, the situation became a property and safety concern. He says we can be considerate neighbors without accepting threats, and I cannot really disagree with that point. We both want the same basic things: to protect our property, avoid unnecessary conflict, and prevent this situation from becoming something more serious.
We simply disagree about whether the best response is to make extra efforts to keep the leaves contained or to report the letter and establish stronger boundaries immediately. We also know that even if we rake every day, the leaves will continue falling until the season ends.
So now I am wondering whether we are overreacting or whether my husband is right to take the threat seriously. Would it be unreasonable to choose option A, rake more frequently, and avoid escalating the situation when we cannot prove who wrote the letter? Or is option B the more sensible response because someone has already threatened to damage trees that are entirely on our property? We are willing to be considerate and keep our yard clean,
but we do not believe anyone has the right to threaten our property instead of simply talking to us. What would you do in our situation: quietly make an extra effort with the leaves, or take the letter to the police and make it clear that nobody is welcome to enter our property?
Our Beautiful Backyard Trees Became The Center Of A Neighbor’s Threatening Behavior
I never imagined that something as ordinary as having a few trees in our backyard would eventually turn into one of the most uncomfortable situations we have experienced with our neighbors. My husband and I have always enjoyed living in our home, especially because we have a decent-sized yard with several beautiful chestnut trees. They provide plenty of shade during the summer, make the property look attractive, and give us some privacy from the houses surrounding ours. Some of these trees have been growing here for years, and we have always considered them an important part of our home. We never thought that something as natural as falling leaves could become the reason someone would threaten us.
Every year, when autumn arrives, our chestnut trees begin dropping leaves almost constantly. Anyone who has several mature trees understands how quickly a yard can become covered in leaves during this season. Even after spending an afternoon cleaning everything, another strong breeze can cover the grass again. We have never denied that some of those leaves travel beyond our property. Whenever the wind blows in the direction of our neighbor’s yard, quite a few leaves end up collecting near his fence, driveway, and garden. We understand that this can be annoying, especially for someone who prefers keeping their outdoor space perfectly clean.
We have always tried to be responsible about maintaining our property. My husband usually handles the heavier outdoor work, while I help with smaller cleaning tasks and organizing the garden. We regularly rake the leaves, collect fallen branches, and make sure the trees are healthy. However, we both have jobs and other responsibilities, so we cannot spend every hour outside cleaning leaves. Sometimes we rake them in the morning, and by the afternoon, another layer has fallen. Other times, we leave the cleanup until the weekend because we simply do not have enough time during the week. We never intentionally allow leaves to pile up on someone else’s property, but we also cannot control where the wind carries them.
Our relationship with the neighbor living next to that side of our yard has never been particularly good. We have lived beside him long enough to recognize that he can become irritated over relatively small things. There have been disagreements in the past involving ordinary neighborhood matters, and some of those conversations ended with both sides feeling frustrated. We have tried to keep our distance whenever possible because we do not enjoy arguing with people who live only a few feet away from our home. We believe having a peaceful neighborhood is important, and we would rather avoid unnecessary confrontations than turn every disagreement into a personal conflict.
Despite our previous issues, we have never considered him someone we needed to be afraid of. We usually greeted him politely when we crossed paths, and we never deliberately did anything to make his life difficult. We understood that neighbors do not have to become close friends, but basic respect should be enough to maintain a reasonable relationship. We also assumed that if something we were doing genuinely bothered him, he would simply speak to us about it. After all, we are adults, and there is no reason two households should be unable to discuss something as ordinary as fallen leaves.
The strange thing is that he has never directly complained to us about the chestnut trees. Not once has he knocked on our door to ask whether we could clean the leaves more frequently. He has never stopped my husband while we were working in the garden to explain that the leaves were becoming a problem. We have not received a polite message or even a casual comment about the situation. If he had approached us respectfully, we probably would have made an effort to adjust our cleaning routine. We could have checked the fence line more often and collected the leaves before they accumulated. It would not have been difficult, and we would have preferred that solution over having tension between neighboring households.
Instead, everything changed when my husband checked our mailbox one morning and discovered an unusual envelope inside. At first, he thought it was ordinary mail that had somehow arrived without a visible stamp. However, when he looked more closely, he noticed there was no return address, no sender’s name, and no postage. Someone had apparently placed it directly inside our mailbox. The envelope was not particularly unusual, but the fact that it had no identifying information immediately made us curious about who had left it.
My husband opened it while standing near the front entrance, and after reading the message, his expression changed. He handed it to me without saying much. The letter contained only a few sentences, but the wording was aggressive enough to make us both uncomfortable. It complained about the leaves from our trees blowing into the neighboring yard and warned us that if we did not deal with the problem, the person responsible would deal with the trees themselves. There was no signature, no explanation, and no attempt to communicate like a normal neighbor. It was simply an anonymous threat directed at something that belonged to us.
I read the letter several times because I initially thought I might have misunderstood what it meant. I could understand someone being frustrated about cleaning leaves, but threatening to damage or destroy another person’s trees seemed completely unreasonable. These were not dead trees falling apart or dangerous branches hanging over someone’s roof. They were healthy chestnut trees growing entirely within our property boundaries. We had maintained them for years, and there was no legitimate reason for anyone to threaten them simply because some leaves were carried by the wind.
My first reaction was anger, followed by concern about who could have written the message. We immediately thought about the neighbor who had caused problems with us before. He was the person living closest to the trees, and his yard was the one receiving most of the fallen leaves. Considering our previous disagreements, it was difficult not to suspect him. However, we also knew that suspicion was not proof. We could not simply accuse someone of sending an anonymous letter without knowing who had actually placed it inside our mailbox.
My husband wanted to walk directly over to his house and ask whether he had written it. I understood why he wanted to do that, but I was worried about how the conversation might develop. If the neighbor denied everything, we would have no way to prove otherwise. If he became angry, the disagreement could turn into a much bigger confrontation. We had already experienced enough uncomfortable interactions with him, and I did not want another argument happening right outside our homes. I suggested that we take a little time to think before deciding how to respond.
We carefully kept the original letter and envelope instead of throwing them away. My husband also took photographs of both sides so we would have a record of exactly what had been delivered. We agreed that if someone was genuinely threatening to damage our property, we should not ignore the evidence. Even if the message was written in anger and the person never intended to follow through, we wanted to be prepared. We also decided not to leave an angry response in anyone’s mailbox because that would only create another unnecessary problem.
After discussing the situation, we decided to install security cameras around our property. We had talked about getting them before, but this incident made us realize that having some additional security would be helpful. We wanted to monitor the front entrance, mailbox, driveway, and the areas near the trees. We also wanted to know whether anyone was entering our property without permission. We did not install the cameras because we wanted to spy on our neighbors or create trouble. We simply wanted to protect our home and have a record of anything unusual that might happen.
The cameras were installed a few days later, and we checked that they were recording properly. My husband made sure the important areas were visible, especially the parts of the property where someone could potentially approach the trees. We also checked that the recordings were being saved so we would not lose important footage. Since then, we have paid more attention to activity around our yard. Whenever someone approaches the mailbox or walks near the fence, we naturally notice it more than we used to.
Unfortunately, the timing of the letter has made everything more complicated because autumn is still in full swing. Our chestnut trees have not finished dropping their leaves, and there are still plenty of them falling every day. We can rake the yard in the morning, but another gust of wind can carry leaves into the neighboring property before lunchtime. It is almost impossible to prevent every single leaf from crossing the boundary. We have started cleaning more frequently, but we cannot guarantee that the neighbor’s yard will remain completely free of leaves throughout the season.
My husband thinks we should take the letter to the police and explain exactly what happened. He believes that making an official record of the threat is a sensible precaution, especially because the person specifically mentioned doing something to our trees. He also wants to put up clear no-trespassing signs around our property. His argument is that nobody should believe they have permission to enter our yard or interfere with our belongings. He says that even if the person was simply trying to scare us, we should make it clear that threats against our property are not something we will tolerate.
I understand his position, but I am hesitant about immediately involving the authorities. We still do not know who wrote the letter, and we have not experienced any actual damage. I worry that reporting it could create more tension with the neighbors, especially if the person responsible lives right beside us. I do not want to spend the next several years dealing with arguments, complaints, and uncomfortable encounters every time we step outside. At the same time, I realize that avoiding conflict should not mean ignoring a threat that could potentially become serious.
I suggested that we could first make an extra effort to keep the leaves from accumulating near the property line. We could rake more frequently during the busiest part of autumn and collect any leaves that blow toward the neighboring yard whenever we notice them. I am not suggesting that we spend every hour cleaning, but checking the area once or twice a day would not be unreasonable. We have already admitted that sometimes we leave the leaves for a day or two, so perhaps making a small adjustment would prevent further complaints.
My husband disagrees with the idea that cleaning more frequently should be our main response. He says the original problem and the anonymous threat are two separate issues. We can be considerate neighbors and still refuse to accept threatening behavior. According to him, if someone had simply asked us to clean the leaves more often, we would have been happy to cooperate. But leaving an anonymous message threatening to damage our trees changes the situation completely. He believes that giving in without addressing the threat might encourage the person to use similar tactics whenever something else bothers them.
I tried explaining that I was not suggesting we ignore the letter. I still want to keep the cameras running, save the evidence, and document anything suspicious. I simply do not want to turn a manageable disagreement into a serious neighborhood dispute if there is another way to resolve it. We could continue cleaning the leaves while waiting to see whether anything else happens. If someone approaches our trees, enters our property, or leaves another threatening message, we would have a much clearer reason to take further action.
However, my husband believes waiting could be a mistake. He keeps reminding me that the letter was not a polite complaint. It specifically suggested that someone intended to deal with our trees personally. He says we should not wait until a tree is damaged before deciding that the threat deserves attention. He also pointed out that removing or damaging a mature tree could be expensive and emotionally upsetting. We cannot simply replace trees that have taken years to grow because someone else refuses to tolerate autumn leaves.
Another concern is that the trees are not located directly on the property boundary. They are within our yard, and we have always maintained the surrounding area ourselves. We have no intention of allowing branches to become dangerous or causing damage to another property. If there were a genuine issue involving overhanging branches, we would be willing to discuss appropriate trimming. But cutting down healthy trees entirely would be an extreme response to a seasonal inconvenience.
We also started wondering whether the neighbor might have been trying to intimidate us into removing the trees voluntarily. We cannot know his intentions, but the fact that he has never spoken to us directly makes the anonymous letter seem even stranger. If his only concern was the leaves, why not simply knock on our door? Why choose an unsigned threat instead? It is possible that he was angry and wrote something without thinking about the consequences. It is also possible that he genuinely believes he can enter our property and damage the trees. Neither possibility makes us comfortable.
Since installing the cameras, we have not noticed anything that clearly identifies the person responsible for the letter. We have not seen anyone approaching the trees or attempting to enter our yard. The neighbor has also not spoken to us about the situation. Whenever we see him outside, he behaves as though nothing has happened. We continue greeting him politely when necessary, but the atmosphere feels different now. I find myself wondering whether he knows that we received the letter and whether he is waiting to see how we respond.
One afternoon, my husband was collecting leaves near the fence when he noticed that several had gathered in the neighboring yard again. He looked over and briefly considered going to speak with the neighbor. He eventually decided against it because he did not want to start a conversation while feeling frustrated. When he came inside, we discussed the situation again. I told him that if the neighbor ever approached us respectfully, I would be willing to have a calm discussion and agree on a reasonable cleaning schedule during autumn.
He said he would be willing to cooperate too, but only if the conversation remained respectful. He does not want to promise that every leaf will be removed immediately because that is simply unrealistic. We can take responsibility for our own property, but we cannot control the weather or guarantee that leaves will never cross the fence. He believes that reasonable expectations should apply to both households, especially when the problem is caused by something natural rather than deliberate behavior.
I also started thinking about what would happen if the situation continued into winter. Eventually, the trees will stop dropping leaves, and the immediate problem will disappear until the next autumn. But the letter will still exist, and we will still have to live beside someone we suspect of threatening our property. Even if the leaves stop being an issue, there could be another disagreement in the future. I do not want every small neighborhood inconvenience to become an excuse for anonymous messages or threats.
At this point, we have two possible approaches, and neither feels completely satisfying. I could support my husband’s suggestion to take the letter to the police, explain the situation, and put up no-trespassing signs. That would establish that we are taking the threat seriously and create an official record in case anything happens later. On the other hand, we could focus on raking more frequently, keeping the leaves on our side as much as reasonably possible, and continuing to monitor the cameras without immediately escalating the situation.
I know some people might say that we should simply remove the trees if they are causing problems, but I strongly disagree with that idea. These trees are healthy, they belong to us, and they have been part of our yard for years. We should not have to destroy something valuable just because another person dislikes the natural consequences of living near mature trees. At the same time, I do not want to be unreasonable or pretend that our neighbor has no reason to be annoyed when leaves repeatedly blow into his yard.
My husband and I have not made a final decision yet. We are continuing to clean the leaves, keeping the original letter somewhere safe, and checking our security cameras regularly. We have also agreed that neither of us will confront the neighbor while angry or make accusations without evidence. If the situation develops further, we will consider contacting the appropriate authorities and asking what legal steps are available to protect our property.
What bothers me most is that this entire situation could probably have been avoided with one normal conversation. A simple request to rake the leaves more often would likely have solved the original problem. Instead, someone chose to leave an anonymous threat in our mailbox, and now we feel uncomfortable in our own backyard. We want to be respectful neighbors, but we also want to know that our property and belongings are safe.
So, are we wrong for refusing to cut down our chestnut trees and considering the anonymous letter a serious threat? Should we choose option A, make an extra effort to clean the leaves throughout the season, and avoid turning this into a bigger dispute? Or should we choose option B, take the letter to the police, install no-trespassing signs, and make it clear that nobody has permission to interfere with our trees? We are willing to compromise about the leaves, but we do not believe that anyone should be allowed to threaten our property instead of simply talking to us. I genuinely want to know how other people would handle this situation, especially if they had to continue living next door to the person they suspected was responsible.





