I never expected a disagreement over a bottle of alcohol to create such a tense situation between my wife and me, especially because the person involved was someone we both genuinely liked. My wife has a wonderful friend who comes over regularly to do my wife’s hair. Over time, her friend became a friend of mine too. She isn’t just someone who comes over, does the hair, and immediately leaves. Usually, she stays for dinner, watches a movie with us, and spends several hours hanging out. We have had plenty of enjoyable evenings together, and I have always been happy to have her in our home. My wife also really appreciates the arrangement because professional hair services can be expensive, and having a trusted friend handle her hair saves her a significant amount of money. Whenever the friend comes over, my wife usually makes dinner, gets snacks, and does whatever she can to make the evening comfortable for everyone.

My wife and her friend also have a little tradition whenever they spend an evening together. They like to take shots throughout the night while they talk, laugh, and catch up. My wife normally buys a bottle of their favorite liquor specifically for these occasions. I have never had a problem with that. It is their tradition, and I don’t mind them enjoying themselves responsibly in our home. The important detail is that I have my own collection of spirits that I keep separately. Some of the bottles in my collection are fairly expensive, and I don’t buy them simply because I want to get drunk. Some were gifts, while others are bottles I specifically searched for and purchased because I enjoy tasting them or wanted to keep them for a particular occasion. My wife knows how I feel about my collection and generally respects it. I have never told her that she can’t have a drink, but there is a clear difference between the regular liquor we buy for casual evenings and the expensive bottles I intentionally keep.

Last night, however, my wife apparently forgot to pick up their usual bottle. She may have been running late or simply had too many things going on, because when her friend was about to arrive, my wife suddenly realized there was nothing for them to use for their usual shots. She came to me and asked if I could open one of the bottles from my collection as a substitute. I immediately knew which bottles she was talking about, and I told her I would rather not open one of those. I suggested that we could order something or send someone to the store to pick up the liquor they normally drink. My wife said that would be inconvenient because her friend was already on the way and she didn’t want to make the evening complicated. I reminded her that we had plenty of other drinks in the house, but none of them were what they wanted for their shots. She then asked again if I could just open one of my bottles because, in her words, it was “only one bottle.”

That phrase bothered me more than I expected. I explained that I understood it was only one bottle to her, but it wasn’t just an ordinary bottle to me. The particular bottle she wanted me to open was expensive, and I had been saving it. I wasn’t refusing because I wanted to control what my wife or her friend drank. I simply didn’t want to open something from my personal collection because someone had forgotten to buy the regular bottle. My wife became irritated and told me I was being overly protective of alcohol. She said that her friend wasn’t some random guest and that we had all become friends. I agreed completely, but I still didn’t understand why friendship meant she was entitled to something from my collection. I told my wife that if she wanted to buy a bottle for them, I had no problem with it, but I didn’t want to open one of mine just so they could take shots.

Things got more awkward when her friend arrived. My wife mentioned that I wouldn’t open one of my expensive bottles, and I could immediately tell that the mood had changed. Her friend initially laughed and said it wasn’t a big deal, but my wife kept bringing it up. She said that I was making the situation unnecessarily difficult and that her friend had come over to help her with her hair and spend time with us. I felt uncomfortable because I never wanted the friend to think I was upset with her. I told her directly that I had nothing against her and that she was welcome in our home. I explained that I simply had certain bottles I wanted to keep unopened. She said she understood, but I could tell the situation had become uncomfortable for everyone. Instead of enjoying the evening, I found myself wondering whether I had somehow become the bad guy over something as simple as a bottle.

Later, my wife and I had a private argument about it. She told me that I had embarrassed her in front of her friend and made it seem as though I cared more about an expensive bottle than making someone feel welcome. I told her that wasn’t fair. I had offered alternatives, and I hadn’t refused to let them drink anything. I simply didn’t want to open a bottle that I had deliberately purchased for my collection. I also pointed out that her friend wasn’t coming over as a paying customer expecting us to provide unlimited drinks. She was a friend coming over to do my wife’s hair, and my wife had already planned to provide dinner and drinks as part of their usual evening. Forgetting to buy the usual liquor didn’t suddenly make my private collection communal property. My wife argued that I could easily replace the bottle later, but I told her that wasn’t the point. If I opened every expensive bottle simply because someone wanted to drink it, there wouldn’t be much of a collection left.

Eventually, I told my wife that I wasn’t trying to ruin their evening or disrespect her friend. I actually like having her around, and I appreciate the friendship they have. I just believe that people are allowed to have personal belongings, even inside a marriage, and that includes things they have spent their own money collecting. If my wife wants a particular bottle for their next hair night, I’ll happily make sure we have one available. What I don’t want is for my collection to become the automatic backup whenever they forget to buy something. By the end of the night, my wife was still annoyed with me, although the argument eventually died down. I honestly don’t know whether I handled the situation badly or whether my wife was being unreasonable by expecting me to open something expensive simply because her friend wanted to take shots. I wasn’t trying to be cheap or rude. I just wanted to keep something that belonged to me unopened. Now I’m wondering whether refusing the bottle was actually disrespectful, or whether my wife should have respected my boundary in the first place.

Read Story…

AITA for refusing to open a bottle from my collection for a guest?

My wife has a wonderful friend who comes over to do hair. She became my friend too & after she cuts/colors my wifes hair, she stays over to eat dinner, watch a movie whatever; always a nice evening. My wife highly appreciates when her friend comes over, hair stylists are $$, so wife usually takes care of dinner & does whatever to make the evening comfortable etc… Wife & friend like to do shots throughout the night (their tradition) & wife always picks up a bottle of their favorite liquor. Except for last night, I guess wife ran late or forgot it & there was no liquor for them to shoot. Before the friend arrived, wife asked me if I could open a bottle from my stash as a substitute.

Ive an expensive large collection of scotch & premium liquors (schnapps, grappa, brandy/cognac/armagnac etc..). Ive meticulously purchased or brought them home with me in luggage from abroad. I dont serve liquor like this unless for others connoisseurs who appreciate the spirit. Liquor doesnt spoil so can last indefinitely. I dont waste them, they are savored, revered & treated like gold; a bottle could last months to years. I know it sounds snobbish or hoity-toity to share my collection with specific people but I dont care; this is my hobby & the expense & sacrifices I undertook to acquire some of these bottles means I wont ever change this stance. Im not opening a $200 bottle to guzzle it indiscriminately with people who dont appreciate its nuances.

I know these are my unique tastes & judgement but its also my collection.

I know our friend’s (& my wife’s) tastes and therefore I refused. They will either want to do shots of the liquor or mix it with coca cola, a huge sin IMO. Wife was pissy. Moreso at herself for forgetting a bottle & with me for being snobby & rigid, as she put it. Our friend comes over to do a huge favor & we cant even offer her a drink. I said our friend is not the right audience for for a 15 year old bottle.

Nothing personal against her, but I know she doesnt appreciate it or even has a taste for it & there are other liquors for shooting/mixing purposes. Surely if we had anything else to offer her, I’d have opened it by now but the scotch is staying in the cabinet tonight. I offered to go to the store for them but by the time we realized, liquor store had closed. I said sorry you forgot to buy liquor but my collection is not up for grabs. I did go get some of our friend’s favorite beer so they would have something to drink.

Wife is still pissy that I’m snobby with my liquor & ruined their shot tradition when they do hair. I said Ive a right to be discriminatory with quality liquor that I personally flew home in luggage myself & spent large $ for. I said sorry but Im not treating barrel aged spirit like bottom shelf plastic bottle vodka at a college party.

EDIT: I know I may come across as hoity-toity and if this earns an asshole judgement, so be it. You wouldn’t open a cellared 25 year Bordeaux when you need cooking wine. You wouldnt toss the keys to a Ferrari to a 16 year old with a fresh driving permit. Same with opening barrel aged spirit for those who dont appreciate it and outright abuse it by mixing with soda. There are some finer things in life that come with a lofty price tag and dont deserve to be squandered frivolously. Or else why even spend this kind of money and collect them in the first place?

EDIT2: Im not sure why its missed so often. The liquor store was closed by the time wife and I had the discussion about no liquor in the house.

A Simple Bottle of Alcohol Turns Into a Serious Argument Between Husband and Wife

I never thought a disagreement over a bottle of alcohol would turn into a serious argument between my wife and me, but somehow that is exactly what happened. The person involved wasn’t even a stranger. She is one of my wife’s closest friends, and over the years, she has become a friend of mine as well. She regularly comes to our house to cut and color my wife’s hair. What started as a professional arrangement eventually became a genuine friendship. After finishing my wife’s hair, she usually stays for dinner, watches a movie with us, and spends the rest of the evening hanging out. We have had countless enjoyable nights together, so there is no personal problem between me and her.

My wife appreciates her friend tremendously because professional hair services can be expensive. Her friend does an excellent job, and my wife trusts her completely. Instead of paying a salon every time she needs her hair done, my wife can have her friend come over, and they turn the whole thing into a social evening. My wife usually makes dinner, buys snacks, and makes sure everything is comfortable. I have always thought it was a pretty nice arrangement. Her friend helps my wife with her hair, and in return, we treat her like a welcome guest in our home.

There is also a tradition that my wife and her friend have developed over time. They like to take shots together throughout the evening. It isn’t something I participate in much, but I know they enjoy it. They talk about their lives, laugh about things, watch movies, and occasionally take another shot. My wife normally buys a bottle of their favorite liquor specifically for these evenings. I have never objected to that arrangement. As far as I’m concerned, adults can enjoy themselves responsibly, and it has never caused a problem in our home.

The important difference is that I have my own collection of spirits. I collect certain bottles because I enjoy them, not because I want to drink everything as quickly as possible. Some bottles are difficult to find, some were gifts, and some cost significantly more than the liquor my wife and her friend normally drink. I have spent years building the collection slowly. I don’t open a bottle simply because someone wants a drink. Sometimes I buy something specifically because I want to save it for a special occasion.

My wife knows this. She has seen me purchase bottles and knows which ones are part of my collection. She doesn’t normally touch them without asking, and I don’t have a problem with her having her own drinks. We have always had a pretty simple understanding about it. There are bottles that belong to our normal household supply, and there are bottles that I have specifically collected. It has never been an issue before.

Then came last night.

My wife had arranged for her friend to come over to do her hair. Everything seemed completely normal. My wife had planned dinner, and her friend was expected to stay afterward like she usually does. However, sometime before the friend arrived, my wife realized she had forgotten to buy their usual bottle of liquor. Apparently she had been running late and simply didn’t have time to stop at the store.

She came into the room where I was and asked me if I could open one of my bottles as a substitute. I asked which bottle she meant, and she pointed toward my collection. I immediately knew what she wanted. It wasn’t one of the inexpensive bottles we keep around for casual drinking. It was one of the more expensive bottles I had been saving.

I told her I would rather not open that bottle.

She looked surprised and asked why. I explained that I had been saving it and didn’t want to open it just for shots. I wasn’t angry with her, and I wasn’t saying her friend couldn’t have anything to drink. I simply didn’t want to open that particular bottle. I suggested that we could order another bottle or have someone quickly run to the store.

My wife said her friend was already on the way and that she didn’t want to make a big deal about it. She asked me again, saying it was only one bottle. I understood what she meant, but to me, it wasn’t “just one bottle.” It was something I had specifically purchased for my collection.

I reminded her that there were other drinks available in the house. She said those weren’t what they normally used for their shots. I suggested that they could simply have something else that evening or skip the shots altogether. My wife didn’t like that answer.

She said I was being too protective of my alcohol collection. I told her that wasn’t what I was doing. I wasn’t trying to control what she drank or what her friend drank. I just didn’t want something expensive from my personal collection opened because someone had forgotten to buy the regular bottle.

She then brought up how much her friend does for her. She mentioned that her friend saves her a lot of money by doing her hair and that she always comes over happily. I told my wife that I appreciated her friend too. I genuinely do. But I didn’t see how that meant my expensive bottle had to be used as part of the arrangement.

My wife argued that we should make guests feel welcome. I agreed with that principle. In fact, I told her that I thought her friend was welcome in our home and that I had no issue providing dinner, snacks, or ordinary drinks. But I didn’t believe being a good host meant giving a guest anything they happened to want.

She became frustrated and said I was making her feel embarrassed. I asked her how I was embarrassing her when I hadn’t even spoken negatively about her friend. I had simply said no to opening one of my bottles.

My wife then asked what I was saving the bottle for. I told her I didn’t have a specific date or event in mind. I just wanted to keep it unopened until I decided I actually wanted to drink it. That seemed to make her even more annoyed. She said if I didn’t have a specific occasion planned, then there was no reason not to open it.

I disagreed. Something doesn’t need to have a calendar date attached to it before I’m allowed to save it. Sometimes I buy things because I enjoy owning them. I don’t think I need to justify every bottle in my collection.

Her friend eventually arrived while we were still having this disagreement. My wife didn’t want to tell her what was happening at first, but eventually the issue came up. I could immediately see that her friend felt awkward. She said it was completely fine and that they didn’t need to drink anything special.

I appreciated that because I didn’t want her to feel responsible for our argument. I told her she was absolutely welcome to stay and that there was plenty of food and other drinks. She assured me she wasn’t offended.

My wife, however, seemed to remain upset.

The hair appointment continued, but the atmosphere wasn’t quite the same. Normally my wife and her friend would be laughing and talking while I occasionally joined the conversation. This time, I could tell my wife was still thinking about the argument.

After the hair was finished, we had dinner together. I tried to keep things normal because I didn’t want one disagreement to ruin the entire evening. Her friend did her best to keep everyone talking too. Eventually, things became more relaxed.

But the alcohol issue came up again later.

My wife said she still thought I had handled the situation badly. She told me that refusing to open the bottle made it seem like I didn’t trust her or her friend. I told her that trust had nothing to do with it. If I didn’t trust her friend, I wouldn’t have been comfortable having her spend hours in our home. The issue was simply that I had something I valued and didn’t want to open it.

My wife said she could replace the bottle later. I told her that wasn’t the point either. Even if the money could be replaced, I didn’t want to open that specific bottle at that time. Once it was opened, it would no longer be part of my unopened collection.

She accused me of caring more about a bottle than about making her happy. That was probably the part that hurt the most. I told her that I cared about her happiness, but I also believed I was allowed to have personal preferences and boundaries within our marriage.

I asked her whether she would be comfortable with me opening something she had intentionally saved simply because one of my friends wanted it. She paused for a moment and admitted that she probably wouldn’t like that either.

That was when I thought we had finally reached an understanding.

However, she still believed I should have made an exception because it was her friend and because her friend had come over to help her. I told her that I appreciated everything her friend did, but I didn’t want our friendship with her to turn into an expectation that we provide expensive things whenever she visits.

I also made it clear that I wasn’t against buying their usual liquor. If my wife wanted to make sure they had their favorite bottle for future hair nights, I was completely fine with helping her remember to pick it up. We could even keep a backup bottle specifically for those evenings.

What I wasn’t comfortable with was using my personal collection as the emergency backup.

Eventually, my wife stopped arguing and went to bed. Her friend had already left by then. Before leaving, she told me privately that she hadn’t expected any of this and didn’t want me and my wife fighting over her. I told her that none of it was her fault.

Now I’m left wondering whether I was unreasonable. I understand that the bottle was expensive, but money wasn’t the only reason I refused. I collect these bottles because I enjoy them, and I don’t think being married means every possession automatically becomes available to everyone in the house.

At the same time, I can understand why my wife felt embarrassed. She wanted her friend to have a comfortable evening, and their normal tradition suddenly couldn’t happen because she had forgotten to buy the liquor. From her perspective, opening one bottle probably seemed like a small sacrifice.

But from my perspective, she had other options. We could have bought another bottle, ordered something, or simply skipped the shots that night. None of those choices would have prevented her friend from enjoying dinner, watching a movie, or spending time with us.

So now I’m questioning whether I handled this correctly. Was refusing to open an expensive bottle from my personal collection an unreasonable thing to do, especially when the guest was someone we both consider a friend? Or was my wife wrong to expect me to open something I had deliberately chosen to keep unopened just because their usual bottle wasn’t available?

I don’t want this to become a bigger issue than it needs to be. I like my wife’s friend, I enjoy having her around, and I have no problem supporting their hair-night tradition. I just think there should be a difference between being generous and feeling obligated to give someone something simply because they want it. Maybe I was too stubborn about one bottle, or maybe my wife crossed a boundary by assuming that my collection was available whenever their regular liquor wasn’t. I’m honestly not sure anymore, which is why I’m asking whether I was wrong for saying no.